For many New York employers, workers’ compensation is something they rarely think about—until an unexpected audit, claim, or penalty turns it into a costly problem. But understanding and avoiding the most common workers compensation mistakes can protect your business from unnecessary expenses, compliance issues, and stress.
In this guide, we’ll outline the most common workers compensation mistakes and how to prevent them.
At Bene-Care, we help employers throughout Western New York navigate every step of the workers’ compensation process—ensuring accurate reporting, the right coverage, and peace of mind for both you and your employees.
New York State has some of the nation’s strictest workers’ comp deadlines. Employers must report employee injuries within 10 days, maintain current insurance coverage, and cooperate with annual audits. Missing even one of these steps can trigger fines or coverage complications.
Tip: Use a recurring calendar reminder to track reporting and renewal dates. Keep your claim forms and payroll records organized so you can file quickly and accurately.
Visit The New York Workers’ Compensation Board for an employer compliance checklist and official guidance on reporting deadlines.
At Bene-Care, we monitor upcoming compliance changes and deadlines, so our clients never miss an important filing or renewal date.
Misclassification is one of the most common and costly workers compensation mistakes employers make. Each employee’s job type is assigned a classification code, and premiums are based on those codes. Listing a worker incorrectly—such as classifying a technician as clerical—can cause serious audit adjustments or denied claims.
Example: A small construction business that lists its on-site foremen as “office staff” could face back premiums plus penalties once the state uncovers the error.
Bene-Care Tip: Review your employee list annually, especially if job duties change. Our specialists verify that your classifications meet New York State standards and reflect your true risk exposure.
Failing to reconcile payroll regularly is one of the most overlooked workers compensation mistakes. Your payroll directly affects your workers’ comp premium, yet many employers rely on outdated numbers or manual spreadsheets. Over- or under-reporting wages can distort premiums and trigger corrections during audits.
Best practice: Reconcile payroll monthly and make sure your workers’ comp reports align with your payroll provider.
If you switch systems mid-year, confirm that wage data transfers correctly to your insurer or TPA. Missing or mismatched numbers can delay claim payments or inflate premiums.
Learn how integrated payroll and workers’ comp reporting simplifies compliance on our Payroll Solutions page.
Workers’ compensation claims can unravel without consistent safety documentation. A missing training log or inspection record may slow claim approval—or worse, reduce benefits.
What to do:
Keep digital copies of every safety training session and sign-in sheet.
Store inspection reports and incident summaries in a secure, backed-up folder.
Review logs quarterly to confirm all staff have received required training.
Beyond compliance, safety programs help lower premiums by reducing claims frequency. Bene-Care helps employers integrate risk management and training resources that reinforce a culture of safety at work.
Your business changes over time—your workers’ compensation policy should, too. Adding new job roles, locations, or equipment without updating your policy can leave coverage gaps.
Action Step: Review your policy every year and whenever your operations shift. A quick coverage check can prevent uncovered claims or costly retroactive premiums.
Treating coverage as “set it and forget it” is among the most costly workers compensation mistakes.
Our team at Bene-Care regularly reviews client policies to ensure every employee and risk is covered. Whether you’re expanding, hiring, or shifting your business model, we help you stay compliant and protected.
When an employee is injured, clear communication between the employer, insurance carrier, and employee is essential. Many claims become complicated simply because no one follows up.
Avoid this mistake by:
Reporting injuries immediately—even if they seem minor.
Staying in contact with the injured employee during recovery.
Documenting all communication with your insurance carrier.
A compassionate, proactive approach not only helps your employee feel supported—it can also shorten recovery time and reduce lost wages or disputes.
Partnering with experienced advisors helps you avoid workers compensation mistakes before they become expensive. Managing compliance, claims, and audits alone can be overwhelming. Working with trusted local experts saves valuable time and resources while ensuring you stay compliant.
At Bene-Care, our commercial insurance specialists:
Evaluate your current coverage for accuracy and compliance.
Identify gaps in classification, reporting, and documentation.
Provide year-round audit and renewal support.
Serve as your advocate in the event of a claim.
We take the guesswork out of workers’ compensation—so you can focus on running your business with confidence.
Avoiding workers compensation mistakes isn’t just about avoiding penalties—it’s about creating a safer, more secure workplace for everyone. By keeping records accurate, policies updated, and communication open, you’re investing in your company’s long-term stability.
Bene-Care’s experienced advisors are here to help you stay compliant, control costs, and protect your people.
Ready to simplify workers’ comp management?
Contact Bene-Care today to connect with a local commercial insurance expert.
Recruitment
Onboarding
Benefits
Third-Party Administration
Time & Attendance
Payroll
401K
HR+
Business & Commercial Insurance
Auto/Home/Umbrella
Health/Dental/Vision
iSolved
Umbrella Tech